At the Intersection of CAD and CAE

Mentoring is key to convergence success stories.

Mentoring is key to convergence success stories.

SolidWorks’ flagship mechanical CAD program includes simulation tools in its modeling environment. Image courtesy of SolidWorks.


Look at any standard CAD program and you’ll find some form of simulation already integrated. SolidWorks Standard comes with first-pass analysis tools, targeting the early-concept design phase.

Autodesk Inventor comes with dynamic simulation and stress analysis. Solid Edge offers parts, assembly and computational fluid dynamics (CFD) simulations, with varying sophistication at different price points. 

From the outset, CAD and simulation appear to be converging, leading engineers to identify and eliminate impractical concepts much earlier in the design process. 

“We’ve gotten to a place where early adopters, innovators and pioneers [in the CAD community] are willing try out simulation-driven design,” says Joe Walsh, founder of the membership-based Analysis, Simulation & Systems Engineering Software Strategies (ASSESS) Initiative.

For the trend to become widespread, Walsh believes a key barrier needs to be removed. 

“First, the tools need to be easy enough for the designers to use without becoming a simulation expert,” Walsh says. 

This calls for a delicate balance. The designer-targeted simulation tools must employ terminologies familiar to the design, not a simulation expert. But it must also be extensive enough to tackle a range of linear, nonlinear, fluid flow and thermal flow to be useful. 

Don’t Water Down CAE

Many standard CAD packages offer some basic simulation tools at no extra cost. This is especially true of vendors that have both CAD and simulation products in their portfolio, such as Autodesk, Dassault Systèmes, Siemens and PTC. Vendors expect the familiarity with simulation inside CAD may increase adoption of higher-end simulation programs. It was a trend that began more than 10 years ago.

Mainstream CAD program Autodesk Inventor, shown here, has integrated many simulation features into its modeling environment. Image courtesy of Autodesk.

The mistake made by some vendors in the early days “was to water down the simulation tools given to the CAD users, because they were worried it might affect sales of their high-end simulation tools,” recalls Keith Meintjes, fellow and executive consultant for simulation, CIMdata.

Although simplifying simulation tools to make them accessible for designers is the right approach, “reducing the physics in it” to create a watered-down version is not appropriate, Meintjes warns. Some early attempts to integrate simulation in CAD resulted in tools limited to linear physics, only good for single-component analysis. Such tools may be too limited to be effective enough. 

Accessible CAE

The barrier to entry to CAE can be lowered by programming and automating decisions that the designers are unequipped to make, such as mesh type or coarseness, Walsh points out. It could be further lowered by careful assessment of the terminology used in the simulation interface, he adds.

“Most of the designers design geometry; they do not design the function of a product,” he points out. “For them, loading and boundary conditions are unfamiliar terms.” 

This issue, however, may not be solved just by revamping the user interface. It may involve training designers to describe products functions and physics in software-calculable values. 

“We’re making progress in that front, but we’re not there yet,” Walsh says.

“You might find that, in some companies, many CAD operators have a two-year associate degree, but they may not be engineers,” warns Meintjes. “So they might not understand what load cases are, might not know what a von Mises stress is.”

Standard simulation tools usually display analysis results, such as von Mises stress, in color-coded regions. To the untrained eye, they may be impossible to interpret, making them utterly meaningless. 

Tailor-made Simulation

One effective method is purpose-built simulation (for example, a CFD simulator for valves or a fan blade stress analysis program), which reduces the choices down to a few geometry parameters. 

These app-style simulations are a phenomenon of the cloud-powered on-demand commerce. Examples can be found in online simulation portals, such as Simulation Hub, which offers various simulation apps to subscribers.

Multiphysics simulation software maker COMSOL is among those betting on this trend. Accordingly, it provides the App Builder function, which allows experts to create purpose-built simulation apps and publish them for wider use.

Though easy to learn and master, these apps are also highly restricted in usage. Unlike general-purpose simulation software, the user cannot repurpose a CFD simulator for valves to run airflow analysis on a race car, for example. It can only be used to test and verify a single scenario with a broad range of variables.

Mentors Needed

The success stories Meintjes have seen are where “the company made the CAE expert responsible for the success of the CAD designer,” he recalls. “In these cases, the CAE experts are often the ones that provide the load case values, and they usually review what the designers did.” 

This formula, he notes, usually leads to first-time design concepts that are highly likely to succeed. There are encouraging signs that the CAD-CAE bond is getting stronger. 

“The designers are getting mentoring from CAE experts more, and the tools are getting easier to use,” Meintjes says. 

Specialization in different types of simulation may also help CAD designers become better at simulation. 

“Some people design wheels, some design axles and some design brakes, for example. Over time, they learn to apply different load cases to the same scenario and develop the knowledge to design ways to deflect stresses,” Meintjes adds.

Benefits

Embedding simulation tools in CAD has two clear benefits, Walsh observes. First, it encourages the designer to use simulation early in the design process. Second, it’s within the designer’s familiar CAD environment, which makes simulation easier for the designer to embrace. 

“The question is not whether we should or shouldn’t. The question is how to do it,” he says. 

“Simulation tools are best used early in the process,” Meintjes notes. “That’s when you have the freedom to explore various design options.”

The first-level simulation conducted by the design engineer doesn’t eliminate the need for input from a simulation expert, Walsh warns. The first-stage simulation is only to ensure that the ones sent to the expert for verification are “more likely to succeed than fail.”

More ASSESS Initiative Coverage

ASSESS Initiative Company Profile

More Autodesk Coverage

Fortifying the MCAD-ECAD Bridge
CAD-embedded plug-ins, mergers and acquisitions, and the quest for common file formats reinforce works already in progress across the industry.
What’s New in AutoCAD 2022?
AutoCAD promises a more connected experience across platforms.
Material Insights into Additive Manufacturing
Use of multiscale material modeling and simulation software is helping expand role of additive manufacturing.
Autodesk Confirms Proposal to Buy Altium Limited
The proposed combination would advance ability to converge design and make via unified design, engineering and manufacturing cloud platform, company says.
IMAGINiT Earns Autodesk Services Accelerator Accreditations 
Accelerator accreditations acknowledge IMAGINiT's ability to deliver value with consulting engagement.
Autodesk Company Profile

More CIMdata Coverage

More COMSOL Coverage

Sponsored Content
The Power of Virtual Experiments
COMSOL users from around the world shared their stories with us, and now we are looking forward to sharing their expertise, insight, and innovative ideas with you.
Sponsored Content
Bringing Lab Courses to Remote Learning Students with Simulation Applications
At the New Jersey Institute of Technology, one professor and his students designed 15 simulation applications for use in engineering and lab courses around the world.
Multiphysics Sparks Innovation in Electronics Design
Multidisciplinary modeling and simulation will play a larger role in solving electronics design challenges.
Simulating a Path to Grid Modernization
As natural disasters, the push for renewables and electrification mount pressure, simulation plays a key role in the U.S. power grid’s redesign and optimization.
Sponsored Content
Making Predictions in Additive Manufacturing with Simulation Apps
Engineers at the Industrial Technology Research Institute built a simulation app that can be used to predict the performance of laser powder bed fusion, an additive manufacturing process. The app saves time and money during the additive manufacturing process for...
A Reality Check for Simulation
Simulation needs test-based validation to be credible.
COMSOL Company Profile

More PTC Coverage

Digital Thread Accelerates Connected Car Development
Digital transformation of the automobile will require a new design approach.
Matterport and PTC Open up Ability to Create AR Experiences for Large Spaces
Customers can now enrich digital twins captured with the Matterport platform with interactive AR experiences called Area Targets.
Parkway Venture Capital Is On Pace to Close Second Fund at $60 Million
Managing partners and serial entrepreneurs Jesse Coors-Blankenship and Gregg Hill leverage knowledge and investment experience with simulation and AI to attract new advisory board members and raise $50 million to date.
A Reality Check for Simulation
Simulation needs test-based validation to be credible.
Editor’s Picks: May 27-June 2, 2021
One of the picks will be chosen as DE’s Editor’s Pick of the Week.
PTC Company Profile

Share This Article

Subscribe to our FREE magazine, FREE email newsletters or both!

Join over 90,000 engineering professionals who get fresh engineering news as soon as it is published.




About the Author

Kenneth Wong's avatar
Kenneth Wong

Kenneth Wong is Digital Engineering’s resident blogger and senior editor. Email him at [email protected] or share your thoughts on this article at digitaleng.news/facebook.

      Follow DE
#24619